Skip to content

RegenPGC Economics

PGC Enterprise Budget

Overview

Many conservation practices look appealing – until cost is considered. Our team wanted to better understand the range of costs that farmers would incur using a Kentucky bluegrass (KBG) perennial groundcover (PGC) approach. This paper details those efforts and estimates the cost to the farmer of KBG perennial groundcover adoption and maintenance.

We found that optimized PGC systems can be cost competitive with business-as-usual practices. This is because groundcover establishment costs — which are incurred in the first year — are recovered in the second year and onward, leading to cost savings and improved profitability in the long run. Specifically, we found that under optimistic assumptions, PGC could pay for itself in 5 years, and that was without crediting PGC with potentially less herbicide, greater stover sales, or yield benefits from improved soil quality and drought mitigation.

Because PGC systems should allow higher levels of sustainable corn stover harvest, our modeling showed that PGC systems in locations with a stover market are even more economically attractive. In the optimistic assumption case, PGC systems with a $50/ton stover market paid back at the end of the second year, and then generated extra revenue going forward!

The Spreadsheet

The spreadsheet “PGC vs. Standard Corn Cost Budget (2024 Rates)” allows for the editing of input prices to reflect the specific costs of on-farm adoption, as well as to edit corn grain prices and stover prices to tailor expected revenue. We also built in pessimistic and optimist scenarios to consider a range of production scenarios, which reflects best case and worst-case conditions in the Midwest. While the optimistic scenario considers pricing and revenue under best-case conditions, the pessimistic scenario considers pricing and revenue with production challenges.

PLEASE NOTE
This Enterprise Budget Spreadsheet IS PROVIDED “AS IS” TO ILLUSTRATE RESEARCH DERVIVED SCEANARIOS AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND. ACCESS TO THIS SPREADSHEET AND THE USE OF ITS CONTENT IS AT THE SOLE RISK OF THE USER. Neither the RegenPGC RESEARCH PROJECT nor ISU nor any of their officers, employees, or agents make any warranty, express or implied, including warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information provided in this spreadsheet. Users shall determine independently whether the spreadsheet content is appropriate for the use intended.

The Paper

Bartel, Cynthia A., Jacobs, Keri L., Moore, Kenneth J., & Raman, D.Raj. (2024). Anticipatory technoeconomic evaluation of Kentucky Bluegrass-based perennial groundcover implementations in large-scale Midwestern US corn production systems. Sustainability, 2024, 16(16), 7112. https://doi.org/10.3390/su16167112. Open access.